×

By continuing on the website you agree to our Privacy & Data Use Policy

Banks Don’t Lend Out Your Money. They Create It.

This week’s blog, in 90 seconds

HOW IT WORKS

Banks Don’t Lend Out Your Money. They Create It.

The familiar story of banks passing savers’ deposits to borrowers is backwards: most money is typed into existence the moment a loan is approved.

GJ

Gareth Jones  ·  Rosefinch Investment Advisors  ·  5 min read

This article is educational and is not investment, tax, or legal advice. Investment advisory services offered through Beacon Global Advisor Network, LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor. Full disclosures

Key takeaways

  • When a commercial bank makes a loan, it creates a matching deposit out of nothing; the loan is not funded by someone else’s savings.
  • The Bank of England confirmed in a 2014 paper that most money in a modern economy is created by commercial banks at the moment they lend.
  • Banks cannot create money without limit; capital rules, funding costs, loan demand, and central bank interest rates all act as brakes.
  • Money is destroyed as well as created, because when a loan is repaid the deposit used to repay it vanishes from the economy.

Here is a question that sounds simple: when a bank approves a mortgage, where does the money come from?

Most people give the same answer. The bank collects deposits from savers, keeps some in reserve, and lends the rest to borrowers. The bank is a middleman, moving money from people who have it to people who need it. It is a tidy story. It is also, in its most important detail, wrong.

The story everyone learns first

The middleman version of banking is the one taught in classrooms for generations. In the textbook model, a saver deposits $1,000, the bank sets aside a required fraction, lends out the remainder, that loan becomes someone else’s deposit, and the cycle repeats. Economists called this the money multiplier, and it implied that the central bank controlled the money supply by controlling the reserves at the bottom of the pyramid.

The appeal of this story is that it matches our intuition about lending. If a friend lends you $50, that $50 left her wallet before it entered yours. Lending, in ordinary life, means handing over something you already have. So it feels natural to assume banks work the same way, as warehouses that take money in one door and push it out another.

But a bank is not a warehouse, and the warehouse story has a problem. It does not describe what actually happens when a loan officer clicks approve.

The moment the money appears

When a bank approves a $300,000 mortgage, nobody checks whether there is $300,000 of savers’ cash sitting in a vault. Nobody moves money out of anyone else’s account. Instead, the bank makes two entries on its own books. On one side, it records a new asset: the loan, which is the borrower’s promise to repay. On the other side, it records a new liability: a deposit of $300,000, freshly credited to the borrower’s account.

That deposit did not exist a moment earlier. It was not transferred from anywhere. It is new money, and it is immediately spendable. The bank’s balance sheet, the running ledger of everything it owns and everything it owes, simply got bigger on both sides at once.

This is not a fringe theory. In 2014, the Bank of England published a paper called Money Creation in the Modern Economy that set out to correct the textbook account. Its authors wrote: “Whenever a bank makes a loan, it simultaneously creates a matching deposit in the borrower’s bank account, thereby creating new money.” The paper noted that bank deposits made up the vast majority of money held by the public at the time, roughly 97 percent, with physical cash accounting for the small remainder. Central banks print the notes in your wallet, but commercial banks create most of the money in your world.

Most modern money is born in a loan agreement and dies in a repayment.

The sequence, in other words, runs opposite to the one we learn. Deposits do not fund loans. Loans create deposits. Saving does not come first and lending second; lending comes first, and the deposits it creates are what the rest of us then hold, spend, and call money.

Why banks cannot simply print without limit

At this point a reasonable person asks: if banks can type money into existence, why don’t they type infinitely? Four brakes keep the system in check, and none of them is a vault full of cash.

Profit and loss. A loan is only an asset if it gets repaid. Every loan a bank creates carries credit risk, and losses come straight out of the bank’s own capital, the cushion of shareholder money that stands between bad loans and failure. Banks that lend recklessly destroy themselves, which history has demonstrated repeatedly.

The money leaves. A borrower does not take out a mortgage to admire the balance. The deposit gets spent, usually landing in an account at a different bank. When that happens, the lending bank must settle the transfer using central bank reserves, a special form of money that banks hold at the central bank. To keep up with those outflows, banks must attract deposits or borrow in money markets, and both cost money. Creating a loan is free; funding its departure is not.

Regulation. International banking rules, often called the Basel framework, require banks to hold capital in proportion to the riskiness of their lending. This caps how far a balance sheet can grow. Notably, the constraint that matters today is capital, not reserves: the US Federal Reserve cut reserve requirements to zero in 2020, and lending did not become infinite, because reserve ratios were never the real brake.

The price of money. Central banks set the interest rate at which reserves are supplied, and that rate ripples through every lending rate in the economy. By making credit more or less expensive, the central bank influences how much borrowing households and businesses want to do. It steers money creation by steering its price, not by rationing a fixed stock.

Money disappears when loans are repaid

The strangest implication of all this is the mirror image. If lending creates money, repayment destroys it. When you pay down a mortgage, the deposit you use for the payment is extinguished along with a slice of the loan. Both sides of the bank’s balance sheet shrink, and that money is simply gone from the economy, in the same bookkeeping sense that it once appeared.

This means the total amount of money in an economy is not a fixed pile being passed around. It breathes. When new lending outpaces repayments, the money supply expands. When households and businesses collectively pay down debt faster than they borrow, the money supply contracts. Economists generally point to this dynamic as one reason downturns that follow credit booms can feel so airless: it is not just that spending slows, but that money itself is being retired.

Why the plumbing is worth knowing

None of this is a secret. The mechanics sit in central bank publications and the footnotes of economics courses. Yet the warehouse story survives because it is simpler and because, for everyday purposes, it rarely matters whether your bank is a middleman or a mint.

Until it does. Knowing the real sequence changes how you hear the news. When a commentator says banks are “sitting on deposits instead of lending them out,” you will notice the sentence has its physics backwards. When debates flare about quantitative easing or credit crunches, you will understand that the argument is really about the pace at which money is being created and destroyed, not about a fixed sum being hoarded or released.

And there is a quieter satisfaction in it, too. The numbers in your banking app feel as solid as coins. In truth, nearly all of them began as a keystroke, an entry on a ledger recording one institution’s promise against another person’s. Money, it turns out, is not a thing that banks store. It is a thing that banks do.

GJ
Gareth Jones, Founder & CEO, Rosefinch Investment Advisors

Cross-border wealth management for families in the US with financial ties to the UK and Europe.

Important disclosures

Important disclosures. Rosefinch Investment Advisors, Inc.
does not provide tax or legal advice. None of the information in this article
should be considered tax or legal advice. You should consult your tax or legal
advisers for information concerning your own specific tax/legal situation.
Investment advisory services offered through Beacon Global Advisor Network,
LLC, a Registered Investment Advisor. Registration as an investment adviser
does not imply a certain level of skill or training and does not in any way
imply Beacon Global Advisor Network, LLC, its advisory representatives, or the
advice and services being offered are endorsed or approved upon by any
regulatory entity including the Securities and Exchange Commission.

The information in this article is provided for general educational
purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to buy or
sell any security. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of
principal, and past performance does not guarantee future results. Nothing in
this article should be interpreted as a recommendation tailored to any
individual situation.

Share:

More Posts